Home   >   CSC-OpenAccess Library   >    Manuscript Information
Reflecting upon Management Systems: Content analysis and synthesis
Manuel F. Suárez-Bar , Juan Ramis-Pujol, Miguel Ángel Heras
Pages - 64 - 86     |    Revised - 30-11-2010     |    Published - 20-12-2010
Volume - 1   Issue - 2    |    Publication Date - December 2010  Table of Contents
MORE INFORMATION
KEYWORDS
Management System, Models and Frameworks, Best Practice
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this paper is to present and discuss/reflect on son well-known quality, strategy and excellence frameworks or models in order to understand the development of the management systems from the classical theory to now. In addition we try to understand the problems or limitation which such kind of models still may have, and in that sense, we proposed a possible macro elements and characteristics of an integral Management System. The studies examine some leading quality, strategy, excellence frameworks or models and discuss/identify their strengths as well as weakness. The chosen models and frameworks are Taylor’s principles (1911), Fayol’s operations (1914), System theory-frameworks (1969), Peter’s and Waterman’s eight excellence attributes (1982), the EFQM European Excellence model (1992), list of best practices (1998), the ISO 9000 norms (2000), Toyota’s 4P model, and Kaplan and Norton’s Management System (2008). Generally, quality, strategy and excellence models and frameworks are inspired by the classical management theory and/or Japanese practices and they recognize the importance to manage any organization using a Management System, which can be integrated by a hard and soft dimensions. Any dimension it is integrated by some elements and some characteristics. Therefore, as a result we attempt to make a first possible description of an integral Management System. On the other hand, our findings indicate that there are tendencies to interpret these models from positivistic view and ignore the soft dimension of the Management System (human aspect), when organization try to implement the model in their struggle to achieve quality and/or excellence, and when they try to translate the strategy in an effective process operation. An integral and holistic Management System can reduce these negative tendencies. The paper aspires to be of interest as much to researchers as to professionals in the manufacturing and service industry, whether they have middle management responsibilities, or are general managers, and also to all those employees whose work is related to some positions of authority (managing people and resources), with the object of understanding the Management System as an integral and holistic view that any organization uses to develop its strategy and translate into operational action and monitor and improve the effectiveness of both.
CITED BY (7)  
1 Cristofaro, M., Giardino, P. L., & Leoni, L. (2021). Back to the Future: A Review and Editorial Agenda of the International Journal of Business Research and Management. International Journal of Business Research and Management (IJBRM), 12(1), 16-33.
2 Jaca, C., Ormazabal, M., Viles, E., & Santos, J. (2018). Environmental comfort based (ECB) methodology as a tool for preparing Kaizen application in a catering service company. The TQM Journal.
3 Jaca, C., Paipa-Galeano, L., Viles, E., & Mateo, R. (2016). The impact of a readiness program for implementing and sustaining continuous improvement processes. The TQM Journal.
4 Jaca, C., Viles, E., Paipa-Galeano, L., Santos, J., & Mateo, R. (2014). Learning 5S principles from Japanese best practitioners: case studies of five manufacturing companies. International Journal of Production Research, 52(15), 4574-4586.
5 Ramírez, K. M. A., & Barraza, M. F. S. (2012). Implementación de un sistema de gestión para una empresa distribuidora de productos farmacéuticos de Ecuador. Un estudio exploratorio. Sotavento MBA, (19), 64-76.
6 Musonda, I. (2012). Construction Health and Safety (H & S) Performance Improvement: A Client-centred Model (Doctoral dissertation, University of Johannesburg).
7 Jan, Z. Use of Kaizen for Quality Enhancement in Business-A Cost-cutting Tool Author Details.
1 Google Scholar 
2 CiteSeerX 
3 Scribd 
4 SlideShare 
5 PDFCAST 
6 PdfSR 
A. Douglas, D. Kirk, C. Brennan, A. Ingram. “Maximizing the benefits of ISO 9000 implementation”, Total Quality Management, 10(4-5):pp. 507-513, 1999
A. Hsieh, C. Chou, C. Cheng. “Job standardization and service quality: a close look at the application of Total Quality Management to the public sector”, Total Quality Management,13(7): pp. 899-912, 2002
A. Van der Wiele, B.G. Dale, A. Williams. "ISO 9000 series registration to total quality management: the transformation journey", International Journal of Quality Science, 2(4):pp.236-252, 1997
B. Jacobs, S. Suckling. "Assessing customer focus using the EFQM Excellence Model: a local government case", The TQM Magazine, 19(4): pp. 366-378. 2007
B. Joubert. “ISO 9000: International quality standards”, Production and Inventory Management Journal, 39(2):pp. 60-65. 1998
B.A. Spencer. "Models of organization and total quality management: A comparison and critical evaluation", Academy of Management Review, 19(3):453.1994
C. George, F. Copper, A. Douglas. "Implementing the EFQM excellence model in a local authority", Managerial Auditing Journal, 18(1-2): pp. 122-127, 2003
C.I. Barnard. ”The Functions of Executive”, Harvard Business University Press Cambridge,MA, originally published in 1938, pp. 81, (1968)
D. Katz, R. L. Kahn. “The Social Psychology of Organizations”, John Wiley & Sons, New York, NY, pp. 66, 752, 52, (1966)
D. Lemack. “Leading students through the management theory jungle by following the path of the seminal theorist. A paradigmatic approach”, Management Decision, 42(10):1309-1325(1313), 2004
D. Sinclair, M. Zairi. "Effective process management through performance measurement Part II - benchmarking total quality -based performance measurement for best practice", Business Process Management Journal, 1(2): pp. 58-66, 1995
D. Wren. “The Evolution of Management Thought”, Ronald Press, New York, NY. (1972)
D.G. McFarlane. "Managing improvement in the public sector", Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, 12(7-8), pp. 1047-1053. 2001
D.S. Steingard. “A postmodern deconstruction of Total Quality Management (TQM)”, Journal of Organizational Change Management, 6(4), pp. 72-87, 1993
E. Ozono, N. Shimizu, H. Takeuchi. “Extreme Toyota, Radical contradictions that drive success at the world best manufacturer”, John Wiley Songs, Inc., New Jerseys, (2008)
E. Yoneyama. “Phenomenology of Lifer: Zen and management”, Society and Business Review, 2(2): pp. 204-217, 2007
EFQM, Club de Excelencia de Gestión. “Modelo EFQM de Excelencia. Versión para el Sector Público y las Organizaciones del Voluntariado”. Madrid, Spain. (in Spanish), (2003)
EFQM. “European Foundations of Quality Management”. EFQM, Brussels,(1999)
F.E. Kast, J.E. Rosennzweigh. “General systems theory: applications for organizations and management”, Academy of Management Journal, December, pp. 447-465.
F.W. Taylor. “Taylor’s Testimony Before the Special House Committee”, Scientific Management, Harper & Brothers, New York, pp. 26-27. 1947b
F.W. Taylor. “The Shop Management”, Scientific Management, Harper & Brothers, New York,p. 30. 1947a
F.W. Taylor. ”The Principles of Scientific Management”, W.W. Norton & Company, New York,NY, adapted published in 1947, pp.36-37, 59 (1911).
G. Hamel. “Moon Shots for Management. Hamel respond”, Harvard Business Review, 87(6):pp. 108-109. (2009b)
G. Hamel. “Moon Shots for Management”, Harvard Business Review, 87(2):92, 2009a
G. Morgan. “Images of Organizations”, Sage, London (1986)
G.K. Kanji, P. Moura. "Performance Measurement and Business Excellence: The reinforcing link for the public sector", Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, 18(1-2), pp.49-56,2007
H. Fayol. ”General and Industrial Management”, Pitman Publishing, New York, NY, adapted published in 1949, (1916)
H. Koontz. “The management theory jungle”, Journal of the Academy of Management,December:174-188(174), 1961
ISO 9000:2000. “Norms ISO-9000 version 2000”. Quality Management. Geneva, Switzerland.2000
J. Dahlgaard, S.M. Dahlgaard-Park. “4P strategy for breakthrough and sustainable development”, European Quality, 10(4):pp. 6-20, 2004
J. Liker. “The Toyota Way – 14 Management Principles from the World’s Greatest Manufacturer”, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, (2004)
J. Petersen.“Defining Lean Production: some conceptual and practical issues”, The TQM Journal, 21(2):127-142. 2009
J.D. Thompson. “Organizations in Action”, McGraw-Hill, New York, NY, pp. 67, (1967)
J.H. Harrington. “The fallacy of universal best practices”, Total Quality Management & Excellence, 15(5-6), 2004
J.M. Shafritz, J.S. Ott. “Classics of Organization Theory”, 5th ed., Harcourt, Orlando, FL.(2001).
K. Kaizer, S. D. Young. “Need cash: look insider your company”, Harvard Business Review,87(5):64-71, 2009
L. Krajeswky, L. Ritzman, M. Malhortra. “Operations Management, process and value chains, Editorial Pearson International, New York, NY, (2007)
L.V. Bertalanffy. ”General Systems Theory”, George Braziller, Nueva York, NY, pp. 36-37,(1968)
M. Harmon, R. Mayer. “Organization Theory for Public Administration”, Fondo de Cultura Económica, México, D.F. (in Spanish), (1999)
M. Shibata, H. Kaneda. “Toyotashiki Saikyo no Keiei (The High Competitive Management of Toyota)”, Nihonkeiwai Shinbun, Tokyo. (in Japanese), pp. 92, (2001)
M. Weber. ”Economy and Society”, University California Press, Berkeley CA, adapted published in 1968, (1922)
M.F. Suárez-Barraza, E. Bou, C. Cataldo. “Finding Standards, Routines and Non-Routines in Toyota Production System (TPS): Standardization without Standardization?” Lean Manufacturing Journal-Reliable Plant Magazine, September 05, pp. 1-32. White papers of www.reliableplant.com, 2008
M.F. Suárez-Barraza, Lingham, T. “Kaizen within Kaizen Teams: Continuous and Process Improvements in a Spanish municipality”, The Asian Journal on Quality, 9(1); pp. 1-21.
N. Wiener. “Cybernetics”, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, (1948)
P. Chung, C. Huang, H. Wang. “ISO 9000 and Public Organizations in Taiwan:Organizational Differences in Implementation Practices with Organization Size, Unionization and Service Types”, Public Organization Review, 1: pp. 391-413, 2001
P. Hermel, J. Ramis-Pujol. "An evolution of excellence: some main trends", The TQM Magazine, 15(4), pp. 242. 2003
P. Senge, Ch. Roberts, R. Rosss, B. Smith, A. Kleiner Senge. ”La Quinta Disciplina en la práctica. Estrategias y herramientas para construir la organización abierta al aprendizaje”,Granica, Buenos Aires. (in Spanish), pp. 123, (1995)
P. Senge. ”The Fifth Discipline: The Art & Practice of the Learning Organization”, Doubleday Currency, London. (1990)
P. Singh, P. Mansour-Nahra. “ISO 9000 in the public sector: a successful case from Australia”, The TQM Magazine, 18(2):pp. 131-142, 2006
R. Kaplan, D. Norton. “Mastering the Management System”, Harvard Business Review, 86(1):pp. 64-65, 2008
R. McAdam, S. Hazlett, C. Casey. "Performance management in the UK public sector.Addressing multiple stakeholder complexity", International Journal of Public Sector Management, 18(3): pp. 256-273, 2005
S. Hino. Inside the Mind of Toyota. Productivity Press, New York, NY. (2006)
S. Mansar, H.A. Reijers. “Best practices in business process redesign: validation of a redesign framework”, Computers in Industry, 56(5), 2005
S. Robbin, Coulter, M. Management, Pearson, México, D.F., pp. 30, (2005)
S. Rusell. "ISO 9000: 2000 and the EFQM excellence model: competition and co-operation".Total Quality Management and Business Excellence, 11(4-6): pp. s6547-s665, 2000
S. Wagner-Tsukamoto. ”Scientific Management revisited. Did Taylorism fail because of a too positive image of human nature”, Journal of Management History, 14(4), pp. 354, 2008
S.M. Dahlgaard-Park, J. Dahlgaard. “Excellence – 25 years evolution”, Journal of Management History, 13(4):371-393. 2007
S.M. Dahlgaard-Park. ”Management control theories and the European business excellent model”, The Asian Journal on Quality, 4(1), 2003
T. S. Khun. “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions”, The University of Chicago Press,Chicago, IL, (1970)
T.H. Davenport, J.E. Short. "The new industrial engineering: Information Technology and Business Process Redesign", Sloan Management Review, 31(4):11, 1990
T.H. Davenport, S.L. Jarvenpaa, M. Beers. "Improving Knowledge Work Processes", Sloan Management Review, 37(4):55, 1996
T.J. Peters, R.H. Waterman. “In Search of Excellence – Lessons from America’s Best-Run Companies”, Harper Collins Publishers, London, pp. 13-16, (1982)
W. Bucley. “Sociology and Modern System Theory”, Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ.(1967)
W.E. Deming. ”New Economics”, Center for Adv.Engineering Study, Cambridge, MA. (1993)
Y. Gorbaneff. ”Problemas, experimentos, juegos de roles para el pensamiento administrativo”, Documentos de Administración, Diciembre, 1: pp. 1-62. (in Spanish), 2007
Y. Monden. “Toyota Production System. An integrated approached to Just in Time”.Engineering & Management Press, Norcross Georgia, pp. 1, 250, 10, (1998)
Y. Tsukuda. “Why is Toyota alone so profitable in these Times of Upheavel?” Nihonkeiwai Shinbun, Tokyo, (in Japanese), 2001
Mr. Manuel F. Suárez-Bar
er - Mexico
manuelfrancisco.suarez@itesm.mx
Mr. Juan Ramis-Pujol
- Spain
Mr. Miguel Ángel Heras
- Spain